The Health Overhaul Illusion
Why we chase big health changes—and how small shifts create real results
Sometimes, when it comes to our health, time plays tricks on us. Because of that, we panic and often overreact.
One exhausting week can make us question everything. Maybe you barely made it through back-to-back meetings, lived off caffeine and takeout, and thought, That’s it—I need a total lifestyle overhaul. I’m going to start waking up at 5 a.m., meal-prepping organic quinoa bowls, and training for a triathlon. But then the weekend comes, you catch up on sleep, and suddenly… life doesn’t seem so dire. (This happens when we gain a little weight, too!)
Health symptoms do the same thing. If your joints ache for a few days, your brain immediately starts running diagnostics. Is this arthritis? An autoimmune disease? Do I need to see a specialist? A few days of knee pain can make you feel like your body is breaking down. But are you, really?
When we don’t feel good, time stretches. One week of illness feels like a month. A few days of back pain feels like forever. But just as this too shall pass is often true, so is the reality that small adjustments—ones that don’t require an entire life overhaul—can have an enormous impact.
Yet we often don’t trust that. We believe in big changes, big interventions, big solutions—when sometimes, what we really need is a small shift, a test, an experiment to get us back on track. The problem isn’t just how we feel—it’s how we think about how we feel.
We are wired to believe that health problems require big solutions. If we’re exhausted, we assume we need a complete lifestyle overhaul. If we’re struggling with weight, we look for the most powerful diet or medication available. If our stress is unmanageable, we seek out an expert program, a special supplement, or a biohacked routine that promises to fix it all.
This thinking is deeply ingrained in our culture and is no accident. From a neuroscience and behavioral perspective, the appeal of big interventions over small, strategic changes is well-documented. Our brains crave certainty and control, and nothing seems more reassuring than an all-encompassing solution that promises to wipe out our struggles in one clean sweep.
Pause Please, Let’s Think About This
But what if tiny, carefully chosen experiments could create more profound change than the massive interventions we’re conditioned to chase? What if, instead of looking outward for health, we turned inward—learning, adapting, and stacking small victories until transformation was inevitable?
And what if we could make these decisions easier by predeciding? Instead of reacting to every tough week or temporary symptom with an all-or-nothing mindset, we could set a simple rule: No big overhauls unless it’s obvious we need one.
Behavioral science tells us that when we’re tired, frustrated, or in pain, we default to big interventions because they feel like they’ll give us control. But in reality, they often waste time, energy, and money.
Predeciding keeps us from spiraling into unnecessary health extremes. Instead of immediately jumping into a restrictive diet, expensive supplement routine, or major medical intervention, we can start small—adjusting the basics first. If the issue resolves, great. If not, we move up the ladder. Maybe that’s the real secret to better health: having a strategy that protects us from our own overwhelmed minds.
The Neuroscience of Big vs. Small Changes
Our brains resist small changes not because they don’t work, but because they lack the dopamine-driven reward system that makes grand gestures feel so compelling.
The Novelty Bias – Research in cognitive neuroscience shows that our brains are wired to seek out new and exciting stimuli. Big, dramatic interventions trigger a flood of dopamine, reinforcing the belief that this is the thing that will finally change everything. But as novelty wears off, motivation fades, and we find ourselves right back where we started.
Cognitive Load and Decision Fatigue – The prefrontal cortex, responsible for decision-making, can only handle so much at once. When we take on massive health changes, we overwhelm this system, increasing the likelihood of failure. A study from Stanford University found that people given too many choices tend to default to doing nothing at all—which explains why ambitious health resolutions so often collapse under their own weight.
The Power of Neuroplasticity – Small, consistent changes rewire the brain more effectively than drastic shifts. Studies like this one also demonstrate that incremental behavioral changes lead to stronger, more enduring neural adaptations than all-or-nothing approaches. When we introduce change in a gradual, low-stress way, we avoid triggering the brain’s resistance mechanisms—which is precisely what allows real transformation to take root.
The Psychology of Being Misled by Big Promises
Marketers know our weaknesses better than we do. They understand the cognitive biases that drive us toward the promise of massive transformation—and they use them to sell solutions that often undermine our own ability to heal and grow.
🪝The "Just One More" Illusion – If we just take this supplement, join this program, or buy this piece of biohacking technology, we’ll finally unlock the health we’ve been chasing. But in reality, this creates a perpetual cycle of external dependency—always needing the next thing rather than trusting our own ability to create change.
✨ Before and After Trap – We are drawn to stories of extreme transformation. The person who went from bedridden to running marathons. The diet that reversed everything in 30 days. But research in social psychology shows that we tend to distort reality when evaluating dramatic success stories, overlooking the months or years of failed attempts and incremental progress that made them possible.
🤳 The Consumer Health Cycle – Many of today’s qualified health experts offer excellent insights—yet almost always with an attached product. An electrolyte mix. A blue light-blocking gadget. A scientifically optimized mattress. And while some of these may be beneficial, they subtly reinforce the idea that better health is something you buy, not something you cultivate from within. Worse, they feed into a cultural belief that we are never enough as we are—that we must always be improving, optimizing, and fixing ourselves. But health isn’t a self-improvement project. It’s a lifelong relationship that evolves as we live.
The Case for Small, Strategic Health Experiments
If we strip away the noise, the question becomes: what is the smallest, most impactful thing I can do right now? Not what supplement should I take? or what program should I follow?—but what shift, however minor, would create real, if not subtle or small momentum?
This is where tiny health experiments become powerful.
💪 They reduce resistance. Small changes slip past the brain’s built-in defenses, allowing habits to take root without triggering overwhelm.
🏆They build confidence. Success breeds success. Each small victory reinforces our ability to influence our health, making larger changes feel easier over time.
📝 They uncover what actually works. Instead of blindly following trends, we learn—through direct experience—what our body responds to best.
When Small Isn’t Enough
Not every health challenge can be solved through tiny experiments. There are times when big interventions are necessary—when small shifts won’t cut through years of dysfunction. If someone is in a crisis state—whether it’s severe metabolic dysfunction, chronic disease, or a critical mental health situation—a more significant overhaul may be needed.
But even then, big changes are often just small changes stacked together. The mistake is thinking that massive change must happen all at once. The most effective overhauls still rely on an experimental mindset—adjusting, tracking, and adapting along the way.
Where to Start: Scaling Down Instead of Adding On
One of the most overlooked strategies in health isn’t what we should add, but what we should remove. Instead of jumping on the latest supplement trend, could we first adjust our diet to include more minerals naturally? Instead of investing in an expensive sleep tracker, could we simply experiment with an earlier bedtime and observe the results?
Consider these low-cost, high-impact experiments:
Nutrition – Instead of chasing the next big diet trend, what happens if you simply remove ultra-processed foods for a week?
Sleep – Before investing in another supplement, what happens if you just cut screen time 30 minutes before bed?
Movement – Before signing up for a 90-day fitness challenge, what happens if you walk outside for 10 minutes a day?
Hydration – Before buying an electrolyte powder, what happens if you just drink more plain water consistently throughout the day?
These are the kinds of scaled-down, free versions of what we’re so often tempted to buy into. They work—not because they’re trendy, but because they remove barriers and allow health to emerge naturally instead of being forced.
The Art of Experimentation: Curiosity Over Perfection
At the core of this approach is curiosity. The answer only comes after the question.
What would happen if I tried this?
How does my body respond to small shifts?
What patterns emerge when I make tiny adjustments?
This is an art, not a science. No algorithm, expert, or product will ever know your body better than you do. The greatest mistake we can make is assuming health is something external—something to be optimized, hacked, or purchased.
True health comes from understanding ourselves first. And the most effective way to do that isn’t through the next big intervention—but through tiny, strategic experiments that allow us to learn, adapt, and ultimately reclaim control over our well-being.
A Thought to Leave You With
Anne-Laure Le Cunff’s book Tiny Experiments is an excellent exploration of how small tests can lead to big insights. The same approach can be applied to health, but only if we understand that small does not mean random. Small changes should be strategic, foundational, and meaningful.
If the promise of big change has left you exhausted, consider this: what if you stopped looking for the next solution and instead tested one small shift this week?
Not because someone told you to. Not because it’s the latest trend. But because it’s the simplest way to prove to yourself that you already have the power to change.
See you Thursday, Health Heroes!
In good health,
Dr. Alice
A little more about Dr. Alice Burron and Strategic Action Health:
Check out our website!
Catch us on Instagram: @the.health.navigator and @dr_burron
You can also connect on LinkedIn, if you want to be professional about it. 👓
And if you’re not subscribed to Health Shift here on Substack — it’s time! This free newsletter is packed with valuable information and approaches to help you on your journey to better, faster healing.
Health Shift: Your Strategic Guide to Making Strategic Health Decisions book is coming May 13, 2025! Mark your calendars!