Should You Eat Only Organic Foods?
Are they the smart choice, or just expensive hype?
Being health-minded, you think I would always purchase organic foods—better for you, better for the planet, and worth the extra cash.
But no, that’s not me. I value low-cost foods, too. I’ve come to balance this out with a hybrid approach by choosing organic with the foods I eat most, like lettuce, but purchasing conventional produce otherwise. But is this wise? I’ve been feeling convicted that maybe I’m poisoning my body with pesticides and fertilizers too much, a little at a time – and as I get older, this could potentially cause issues. Or could it?
Where is this fear coming from? Hold the phone; it’s time to dive into the world of organic foods — using the Health Shift approach.
With organic prices (and even regular prices) soaring, I know other consumers are asking legitimate questions: Does organic really mean pesticide-free? Is it more nutritious? Does it spoil faster? And why does a non-organic apple last three weeks in the fridge while an organic one turns soft in five days? Let’s find out if they’re worth the price.
This post explores facts behind organic farming, food labels, and what consumers really need to know, and I included lots of research links. However, it is not comprehensive, so use it as a springboard to find more information and answer your questions.
For the sake of space and your valuable time, I’m going to answer common questions about organic foods, like lobbing a tennis ball of information back at you after each question so that you can make a healthy decision about whether you should purchase organic foods or not.
Organic refresher, here we go!
What Does “Organic” Actually Mean?
Organic isn’t just a vague wellness trend—it’s a strictly regulated term under the USDA National Organic Program (NOP). To be certified organic, food must meet these requirements:
No synthetic pesticides or fertilizers – Farmers must use natural fertilizers (like manure or compost) and natural pest control methods (e.g., introducing predatory insects).
No GMOs – Organic crops can’t be genetically modified.
No antibiotics or synthetic hormones – Livestock raised organically cannot receive routine antibiotics or artificial growth hormones.
Soil health and sustainability – Organic farmers must use crop rotation and composting techniques to maintain soil fertility.
But organic doesn’t mean pesticide-free. Organic farmers can still use natural pesticides, like neem oil or pyrethrin, which come from plants but can still be harmful in high doses.
Also, organic certification doesn’t always mean small, idyllic farms. Big agriculture has stepped in, and some massive organic farms operate just like conventional farms—without synthetic chemicals.
And organic farms aren’t necessarily better for the environment, either.
Processing: Is Organic Food “Organic” from Farm to Table?
Many assume that if a product is labeled organic, every step of its journey is free of industrial processing. This is not always the case.
Take organic stevia (above) as an example. Even if the plant is grown using the organic methods stated, once it’s harvested, the processing methods can include chemical extraction techniques that aren’t organic at all.
Here’s the basic process of how raw stevia leaves become the ultra-sweet white powder or liquid in your pantry:
Harvesting & Drying – Stevia leaves are harvested and dried.
Extraction – The dried leaves are soaked in water to pull out the sweet compounds called steviol glycosides (the natural sweet components in stevia).
Purification & Refinement – The extract is then treated with solvents, activated carbon, and even ion-exchange resins to remove unwanted flavors — because raw stevia can be a little bitter.
Bleaching & Crystallization – Some forms of stevia undergo bleaching and chemical processing to produce a white, crystalline powder.
Blending with Additives – The final product is often mixed with fillers like erythritol, maltodextrin, or dextrose to improve texture and mimic sugar’s bulk.
By the time it reaches your kitchen, stevia is no longer just a simple ground-up plant—it’s a highly refined extract called E960. I don’t like eating foods called by a number, do you?
It’s incredibly frustrating for consumers who are trying to make better health choices, only to find out that their “healthy” alternative is just another ultra-processed product in disguise.
This is a perfect example of how marketing manipulates health-conscious consumers. The reality is that most stevia products are chemically processed, refined, and often mixed with fillers, sugar alcohols, or additives that may not be much better than the sugar they’re replacing.
It’s part of a bigger problem: people assume “natural” means “healthy” when it often just means derived from something natural, then processed into something unrecognizable. Organic stevia is just one example of hundreds.
So, what’s a consumer supposed to do? For packaged organic foods, the key thing to look for is:
“100% Organic” – Everything in the product is organic.
“Organic” – At least 95% of ingredients are organic.
“Made with Organic Ingredients” – Only 70% of ingredients must be organic.
Just because something says “organic” doesn’t mean it wasn’t processed, refined, or treated in ways that aren’t necessarily “natural.”
Start to do some research on things you think are as natural and healthy as you assume they are. No longer assume. That’s a great place to start.
Is Organic Food Really More Nutritious?
One of the biggest reasons people justify paying more for organic food is the belief that it’s nutrient-dense, but the truth is that it depends.
A 2014 meta-analysis found that organic crops contain higher levels of antioxidants, potentially up to 69% more than conventional crops. Antioxidants help protect cells from damage.
But a 2012 Stanford study found that organic foods aren’t significantly higher in vitamins and minerals than conventional foods. So, if you’re eating organic spinach thinking it’s going to pack an extra punch of iron, you might be disappointed.
From my perspective, there is more evidence to eat organic than conventional, if possible. The fewer synthetic pesticide residues and potentially higher phytonutrients created from plants that had to “fight harder” in nature without chemical pesticides.
Do Organic Foods Spoil Faster?
Yes, they often do. And, believe it or not, that’s a good thing.
Conventional produce lasts longer because it’s often treated with preservatives, wax coatings, or even irradiation to prevent spoilage. Organic foods, on the other hand:
Aren’t treated with fungicides, so they may mold faster.
Aren’t wax-coated, so they dehydrate and shrivel quicker.
Aren’t bred for longevity, just quality.
We’ve trained ourselves to expect perfect, long-lasting produce, but this has come at a cost—nutrients.
In many cases, modern produce is bred for durability, size, and color rather than flavor and nutrition. We must adjust our expectations for organic foods.
That perfectly round, spotless tomato? Probably bland. The knobby, slightly misshapen heirloom tomato? It’s likely bursting with flavor and nutrients.
Consumers need to rethink their expectations—real food spoils and that’s okay.
Can You Just Wash Conventional Produce Instead?
If only it were that easy. Short answer: It helps, but it’s not the same as eating organic.
Washing removes some surface pesticide residues, especially on foods with smooth skins, like apples or cucumbers.
However, many pesticides are systemic, meaning they’re absorbed into the plant itself. Washing can’t remove what’s inside. Instead,
Prioritize organic for high-pesticide foods (strawberries, spinach, bell peppers—see the Dirty Dozen list).
Feel comfortable buying non-organic for low-residue foods (avocados, onions, bananas—see the Clean Fifteen list).
If organic isn’t in your budget, a good rinse or baking soda soak is definitely better than doing nothing at all.
Organic Farmers – What About Them?
Organic farming is more labor-intensive, riskier, and often less profitable than conventional farming. Farmers who choose to go organic must navigate strict regulations, higher costs, and unpredictable challenges that can threaten their livelihood. Some of the biggest obstacles include:
Cross-contamination – Organic certification can be jeopardized if pesticides, herbicides, or genetically modified organisms (GMOs) from neighboring conventional farms drift onto organic crops via wind, water, or even pollinators. This contamination can result in financial losses and the costly process of regaining certification.
Lower yields – Without synthetic fertilizers and chemical pesticides, organic crops typically produce less per acre. Natural alternatives, such as compost and crop rotation, can help improve soil health but don’t always match the efficiency of conventional methods.
Weather risks – Organic farms are particularly vulnerable to extreme weather, pests, and disease outbreaks. Since they avoid synthetic fungicides and insecticides, a bad season can devastate crops with fewer options for recovery.
While organic food often costs more at the store, those higher prices don’t necessarily translate to big profits for farmers.
The cost of organic certification, labor-intensive production methods, and stricter regulations all add up, making it difficult for small organic farmers to compete with large-scale agricultural operations. Despite these challenges, many farmers remain committed to organic practices, driven by a belief in sustainability, soil health, and providing chemical-free food.
Do your homework in your area if you’re interested in local farms and their practices. Supporting local is an incredible benefit for both them and you.
Is Organic Better for the Environment?
Organic farming sounds like an environmental win, but it’s complicated.
🌱 The Good:
Supports soil health through composting and crop rotation.
Reduces chemical runoff into waterways (but does it?).
Encourages biodiversity (more pollinators, fewer monocultures).
🏭 The Bad:
Requires more land to produce the same amount of food.
Lower yields can contribute to deforestation if scaled up.
Some organic pesticides (like copper sulfate) can be harmful in large quantities.
If sustainability is your priority, regenerative organic farming (which actively restores soil health) may be the future of organic. I can only imagine what the cost of regenerative organic foods will be.
The Bottom Line: Is Organic Worth It?
If you have the budget, organic foods—especially for high-pesticide produce—can be a smart choice. But if you’re selective, you can get similar benefits with strategic conventional choices, proper washing, and buying local (support your local farmers!).
Organic is not a magic bullet.
The bigger goal should be:
✔ Eating more whole foods—whether organic or not.
✔ Prioritizing nutrient-dense, flavorful foods over mass-produced, long-lasting varieties.
✔ Supporting local farmers who may use organic practices but aren’t certified.
Ultimately, the best diet isn’t about labels—it’s about real, high-quality food.
Applying CREECS to Organic Foods: Should You Go Organic?
If you're unsure whether buying organic is worth it for you, the CREECS method (Cost, Risk, Effort, Effectiveness, Commitment, Support) can help you make a strategic choice based on your priorities.
💰 Cost – Is it within your budget?
Organic foods cost more on average.
If money is tight, prioritize organic for high-pesticide foods (like berries and leafy greens) while buying conventional low-residue foods (like avocados and bananas).
💡 Check out local farmers’ markets—they often have organic produce at lower prices, even if it’s not USDA-certified.
💫 Risk – What’s the potential downside of conventional foods?
Conventional produce contains more pesticide residues, but the levels are generally within safety limits (depending on your comfort level with government regulations).
Some pesticides used in conventional farming have been linked to hormone disruption and neurotoxicity, but the long-term effects of low-level exposure are debated.
💡 If you’re concerned about pesticides but can’t afford organic, washing and peeling conventional produce can reduce exposure. Peeling, however, removes the nutrients found in the peel.
⏱️ Effort – How much time do you want to spend?
Organic food spoils faster and may require you to shop more to avoid waste.
Finding truly organic and minimally processed foods requires label reading and research, especially for packaged foods.
💡 If you don’t want to think too hard, just follow the Dirty Dozen / Clean Fifteen list to make quick decisions.
🫀Effectiveness – Will eating organic actually benefit your health?
Nutrition: Organic foods may have slightly more antioxidants, but vitamin/mineral differences are minor.
Pesticides: Organic foods have fewer synthetic pesticide residues but not zero pesticides.
Gut health: Some studies suggest that it does.
💡 If your goal is nutrient density, prioritize fresh, local produce over imported organic options, which may lose nutrients in transit.
✍🏻 Commitment – Can you stick to it?
Going fully organic is a long-term commitment and requires adjusting your budget and shopping habits.
If it’s unrealistic, a hybrid approach (organic for certain foods, conventional for others) may be more sustainable.
💡 Make one small change first—switch to organic dairy or buy organic berries, then reassess later.
👪 Support – Do you have the support of your family or community?
Is organic food available where you shop? Some areas have limited options.
Do you have family support? If your household isn’t on board, switching to organic may create friction.
💡 If family members push back on the cost, focus on specific priority foods and compromise on the rest.
Final Verdict
✅ If cost isn’t a big issue, you dislike pesticide exposure, and you have easy access to organic foods—do it!
✅ If cost or effort is a concern, use a hybrid approach (organic when it makes sense, conventional when it doesn’t).
✅ If nutrition is your priority, focus on eating a variety of whole foods—organic or not.
The best food choice is one that fits your values, budget, and lifestyle—not just what the marketing says is healthy for you.
So, how about you? Do you eat organic? Why, or why not — let me know in the comments!
— Dr. Alice
A little more about Dr. Alice Burron and Strategic Action Health:
Check out our website!
Catch us on Instagram: @the.health.navigator and @dr_burron
You can also connect on LinkedIn, if you want to be professional about it. 👓
And if you’re not subscribed to Health Shift here on Substack — it’s time! This free newsletter is packed with valuable information and approaches to help you on your journey to better, faster healing.
Health Shift: Your Strategic Guide to Making Strategic Health Decisions book is coming May 13, 2025! Mark your calendars!